By guest writer Michael Hansen.
With the release of IM+ Proâ€”an instant messaging client for the iPhone/iPod Touch/iPadâ€”with VoiceOver support, I got to thinking: I donâ€™t mind paying $10 to an app developer for an app with full VoiceOver accessibility. However, I do mind paying any amount to a developer for an application that I cannot use. The exception is @Planetbeingâ€™s Signal app, which I would buy regardless because he and the Dev Team have done the jailbreak community a great service with all of their hard work on jailbreaks/unlocks for the iOS platform. @Planetbeingâ€™s app aside (which I havenâ€™t bought yet because I cannot currently access Cydia with VoiceOver), I see no reason to pay for an application that I cannot use, be it an iPhone app or something for my Windows computer.
Palringo Poses Problems
Within the last couple weeks, I purchased Palringo Instant Messenger Premium, developed by Palringo Limited, from the iTunes Store. I was able to log into AOL Instant Messenger (AIM), but was not able to log into Facebook. VoiceOver reported â€œFacebookâ€¦logging in,â€ when I tapped that icon. Even after I confirmed that Palringo accessing Facebook was okay (my account had been frozen because Facebook had not recognized Palringo) I still got the same â€œlogging inâ€ message.
Accessibility Problems Start With AIM
In AIM, the situation was different but no less problematic. While I was able to access my contacts list and receive messages, I was unable to read the messagesâ€”VoiceOver would read the contactâ€™s name but not the message itself. There went $4.99. Thanks, Palringo.
Apple Grants One-Time Refund for Palringoâ€¦Grudgingly
This afternoon, I contacted Apple through the iTunes Store to request a refund for Palringo Instant Messenger Premium, due to inaccessibility. In an e-mail sent at 6:22 PM CDT today, Apple said they would reverse the charge for Palringo Instant Messenger Premiumâ€”just this one time.
â€œI’m sorry to hear that you can’t use â€˜Palringo Instant Messenger Premiumâ€™ with your device,â€ said Lilly, the iTunes Customer Support representative who responded to my request. â€œPlease note that The iTunes Store Terms of Sale state that all sales are final, so this is a one-time exception.â€
So what does Apple expect the blindness community to do? Pay for apps and not be able to use them? Install pirated versions to try them out before buying them in the app store? I donâ€™t think so.
Apple needs to consistently provide refunds to VoiceOver users for inaccessible appsâ€”itâ€™s as simple as that. I will never download pirated applications, but honestly, given that Apple does not have an app trial service, Iâ€™m not surprised that Piracy is as big as it isâ€”the lack of a trial service effects many more people than just VoiceOver users. It is in Appleâ€™s best interests, no matter what way they look at it, to institute a trial serviceâ€”the Android folks have already figured that one out.
I also think that Apple should require developers to list VoiceOver support in their application descriptions in the iTunes store, similar to how they list iOS version compatibility.
Next Steps Likely Uphill
I plan to contact Palringo Limited to ask about future accessibility of their products. I am also going to present my concerns to Apple.
Please stay tuned, as I will write when I have any updates.
Michael Hansen is totally blind and is a senior at Addison Trail High School in Addison, IL. Previously, he was the Editor-in-Chief of the Skyline newspaper at Willowbrook High School in Villa Park, IL, during the 2009-2010 school year. He can be reached at AMTK62 (at) gmail (dot) com.